After 66 Years, Marvel Rewrites Spider-Man’s Origin With New Twist That Changes The Hero Forever

Published Sep 30, 2026, 2:17 PM EDT

Jared is a writer, editor, and Communications Studies graduate who loves popular nerd culture (almost anything to do with Marvel, DC, Star Wars, or The Lord of the Rings) and the interactive storytelling medium. Jared's first console was the PS1, wherein he fell for Spider-Man, Spyro the Dragon, and Crash Bandicoot.

Sign in to your ScreenRant account

Warning! The following contains major SPOILERS for The Amazing Spider-Man #1000 and its special guest anniversary story “I Can Never Rest.”

Maybe rivaled only by Batman or Superman, Spider-Man unquestionably has the most iconic and ubiquitously well-known origin story of any superhero. This is due to the character’s overwhelming and indelible popularity, sure, but it’s also because he arguably has one of the best superhero origin stories ever conceived, folding themes of grief and guilt into a rich batter that’s enhanced by the fact that he’s an orphan, a teenager, and a bookworm—all fairly novel traits for a superhero protagonist created in the 1960s.

Of course, that hasn’t thwarted countless adaptations and continuities from telling it differently, though the core conceit and ethos are typically intact concerning Peter Parker being bitten by a spider (whether it was struck by radioactivity, genetically engineered in a laboratory, and so forth) and must later confront the man who killed Uncle Ben (unless you’re Marc Webb’s Amazing Spider-Man movie, which never saw this crucial part of Peter’s origin story resolved). However, in The Amazing Spider-Man #1000, released today, the classic origin story readers know and love has now been changed forever.

Dan Slott, Marcos Martin, Muntsa Vicente, and Joe Caramagna’s special guest anniversary story in The Amazing Spider-Man #1000, “I Can Never Rest,” tells a fantastic story from the perspective of a New York City police captain named Arthur Simekski (possibly named after legendary Marvel Comics letterer Arthur Simek), who has been painstakingly pursuing a notorious yet petty criminal, dubbed the “Five Boroughs Burglar.” As it turns out, this is the same burglar whom a scorned and indignant Spider-Man let run by, with Arthur being the same cop who scolded Spider-Man for doing so before being dismissed by the web-slinger.

Little did he know that he’d meet Spider-Man again by tending to the burglar’s newest murder scene: the Parker family residence. This isn’t consistent with Amazing Spider-Man #15, as the officer who talks to Spider-Man doesn’t look like the one who talks to Peter, but it’s a welcome retcon because of how poignant and wildly different their interactions become. Understanding how traumatized the family’s nephew must be, Arthur races toward the warehouse where the burglar is holed up, and, before he and his men can flood the place, they see the felon dangling in a spider’s web.

This Amazing Spider-Man #1000 special guest anniversary story concludes by leaping ahead to whenever the present day is. Here, Arthur comes across Spider-Man, who’s in the middle of apprehending Tarantula, and thanks him for giving him closure on a string of cases and a “trigger-happy” murderer that had kept him on duty long past when he intended to retire. Not only does he apologize to Spider-Man—who remembers the police captain, unsurprisingly—but he also empathizes with him letting the burglar go, saying: “He got away from me a couple times.”

“All those people he was hurting… it was eating me alive. You have no idea. So yeah. You screwed up. But then you stepped up. You did what I couldn’t. You caught him, and… thanks to you, only one other person died, when there could’ve been so many more.”

The lovely recontextualization that Slott’s prologue story offers is that even though Peter has always blamed himself for Uncle Ben’s death and cited this devastating incident as the moment he learned the true meaning of ‘power’ and responsibility,’ the police captain explains to him that it’s because of Spider-Man that the burglar wasn’t able to ruin the lives of anybody else. “I Can Never Rest” is the last of the seven special guest anniversary stories and has the honor of closing the book, and it does so phenomenally.

The Amazing Spider-Man #1000 is out now.