Why is it OK to murder people in GTA games, but not to sexually assault them?
If you’re a Grand Theft Auto fan – and among the millions getting stuck into the latest iteration this past week – you’re probably aware the franchise has courted some controversy.
The previous game, GTA 5, featured torture, and was also modded to allow gamers to simulate sexual assault.
Other GTA games have allowed gamers to pay a sex worker for services, and then kill the worker to get their money back. While the sex isn’t depicted, the murder very much is.
GTA 6 is somewhat curbing this trend, balancing out the gratuity featured in previous games by encouraging empathetic behaviours such as putting your rubbish in the bin, rather than throwing it on the floor.
Much of the online debate over the game’s ethics is concerned with whether engaging in the romantic storyline (which includes consensual sex) could be considered virtual infidelity. This is a pleasing change of pace compared to the ethics of virtual torture.
However, you can still enact mass shootings in GTA 6, and blow off innocent people’s heads, in the most immersive and graphically violent ways offered by the franchise so far.
Is such virtual behaviour unethical? And if it is, why?
Charles Sturt University Associate Professor Morgan Luck has formulated a puzzle called the “gamer’s dilemma” to address these tensions – and there is surprisingly little agreement regarding a solution.
What is the gamer’s dilemma?
Most gamers will tell you that intentionally driving over an innocent pedestrian in GTA, and killing them, is ethically OK. There are good grounds for this belief. After all, virtual wrongdoings aren’t real; they are just part of a game.
Also, while there is some evidence that exposure to violent video games is connected to aggressive thoughts and behaviours, there is little research linking virtual wrongdoings to an increased likelihood of their real-world counterparts. Basically, murdering people in a game doesn’t make you more likely to murder in real life.
The problem for the gamer, and the puzzle the gamer’s dilemma seeks to articulate, is that all virtual wrongdoings are just part of a game.
It is true that nobody is really murdered in GTA. But it is also true that nobody is really sexually assaulted in the modded version, nor is anyone actually tortured. But many would argue those latter acts are not ethically acceptable.
And so the challenge for gamers is to morally differentiate between “off-limits” virtual actions, such as sexual assault or torture, from “fair-game” virtual actions.
Solving the gamer’s dilemma
This dilemma has proven to be a sticky problem for philosophers.
The most popular approach is to take the dilemma head-on by trying to identify this moral difference.
Philosopher and University of Iowa professor Stephanie Patridge argues some virtual acts are wrong because of the “incorrigible social meaning” they carry.
This is one way to make sense of what’s going wrong when gamers murder sex workers in GTA: that such media representations unambiguously cast “women in the role of objects of sexual pleasure and violence”.
Patridge argues enjoying such representations exhibits a failing in one’s character to treat a wrongdoing (oppression) with adequate concern.
Other scholars take the view that what matters isn’t what you do in a game, but the context in which you do it.
For instance, Santa Clara University professor Eric Ramirez argues a virtual wrongdoing, whether it is murder or torture, is morally salient when it is so realistic that it is experienced as if it were real.
Empirical research supports this concern over realism; a virtual reality murder simulator is seen as ethically distinct to virtual murder on an arcade machine.
If Ramirez is right, and this concern over realism is justified, this might be a problem for GTA 6 given reports of how realistic it is.
A third approach to the gamer’s dilemma involves resisting the underlying moral foundations of the dilemma altogether. It denies that the intuitions of the dilemma – that virtual murder is OK and virtual sexual assault is not – are based on moral grounds.
Macquarie University professor Paul Formosa and I have argued that instead, these intuitions might be guided by conventional norms that are specific to video games and their history.
For example, perhaps we wouldn’t be so ready to endorse virtual murder if it weren’t for the widespread acceptance of killing “bad guys” in shooter games.
What should you do?
While there have been several promising approaches to solving the gamer’s dilemma, no single approach has proven successful.
Of course, philosophers don’t claim the ethics of video games should mirror the ethics of real life. This would be overly moralistic.
However, the gamer’s dilemma reminds us that the virtuality of our conduct can’t always excuse it. The puzzle is in trying to explain why.
In the meantime, gamers are left in a dubious position. Perhaps it’s worth pondering the next time you drive down the roads of Leonida, ready to run over some innocent pedestrians.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.