Five months on, Bengal waits for government to govern, not oppose

Bengal’s intellectual restlessness, literary traditions, and appetite for debate are its strengths, not failings. The government should address the structural failures that constrain the state, not erode what gives it distinction.

The government should address the structural failures that constrain the state, not erode what gives it distinction.

AI Narration

Listen

00:00

Thank you for your feedback.

Your feedback has been reported succesfully.

2 min readOct 22, 2026 06:15 AM IST First published on: Oct 22, 2026 at 06:15 AM IST

If there is one thing that stands out in West Bengal’s annual Durga Puja, it is its largesse as a public commons — the sarbojonin — where there is room for the devout, the argumentative, and the sceptic. And so, year after year, alongside the beat of the dhak, the crowds at the pandals, the food stalls that dot the festive perimeters, a constant has been book stalls, many set up by Left parties. The conviction that political differences need not extinguish cultural fellowship seems to have faltered this year. Across the state, reports of vandalism of these book stalls suggest a disturbing narrowing of that common ground.

The tension also echoes wider concerns about the BJP government’s priorities since coming to power in May on the promise of change. In the five months since, its actions show the instincts of an opposition party on the street, drawn to the readily mobilised terrain of identity politics. It shows few signs of getting down to the harder work of governance. The disquieting spectacle of arrested TMC members being paraded through their erstwhile strongholds by police and paramilitary forces soon after the BJP came to power; the passage of the West Bengal Universities and Colleges (Administration and Regulation) (Amendment) Bill, 2026, and the controversial Anti-Goonda Bill 2026 raise questions about institutional autonomy and administrative overreach. Together, these developments evoke an older playbook in the state in which power travelled through patronage, muscle and systemic impunity — the culture the BJP promised to change.

While investigations are ongoing to identify the miscreants, at least two BJP leaders have come out in condemnation of the acts of vandalism, among them Finance Minister Swapan Dasgupta. His insistence that ideological differences cannot justify the destruction of books sits uneasily alongside Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari’s suggestion that the Left sell books from its own offices. Bengal has urgent tasks before it: Creating jobs and strengthening public institutions. Its literary traditions and appetite for debate are its strengths. The government should address the structural failures that constrain the state, not erode what gives it distinction.